During the pandemic, Pakistan’s schools, like schools everywhere, were forced to think about digital learning in a hurry. Lessons moved online where they could, television and radio were used where they could not, and teachers who had never taught through a screen suddenly had to learn how. The crisis passed, but the questions it raised have not gone away. What does digital learning actually mean for a country where many schools lack reliable electricity, let alone internet?
The answer, increasingly, is that devices alone are not enough. A tablet in a classroom without connectivity, without trained teachers and without content in a language children understand is not a solution. It is a photo opportunity. The real digital divide in Pakistan’s classrooms is not only about hardware. It is about everything that makes hardware useful.
The Gap Is Real, and It Is Uneven
The divide runs in several directions at once. Between cities and villages, the gap is stark. A private school in Lahore or Karachi may have smart boards, computer labs and high-speed internet. A government school in a rural district may struggle with basic facilities, let alone digital tools. Between boys and girls, the gap can widen too, particularly where families are less willing to invest in a daughter’s access to technology.
There is also a gap between schools and homes. Even if a school has computers, a child who returns to a home without electricity, internet or a device cannot practise what they have learned. During remote learning, that gap became painfully visible. Some children continued their education from a laptop in a quiet room. Others shared a single phone with siblings, or had no access at all.
None of this is unique to Pakistan. Countries around the world face similar divides. What makes Pakistan’s case urgent is scale. With one of the largest school-age populations in the world, and millions of children already out of school, the cost of getting digital learning wrong is high. The opportunity, if it is done well, is also large.
Teachers Are the Missing Piece
Ask any teacher who has tried to use technology in the classroom, and they will tell you the same thing: the device is the easy part. The hard part is knowing how to use it to teach. A teacher who has spent years teaching with a blackboard and a textbook cannot be expected to become a digital educator overnight, simply because a tablet has arrived.
Teacher training is therefore central, and it is often the most neglected part of digital education programmes. Training needs to be practical, ongoing and relevant to the subjects teachers actually teach. It needs to show a maths teacher how to use a simulation, a science teacher how to run a virtual experiment, and a language teacher how to find reading material that matches the curriculum. A one-off workshop is not enough. Teachers need support, time to practise, and a way to ask for help when things go wrong.
There is also a question of confidence. Many teachers, particularly older ones, worry that technology will expose their lack of familiarity, or that it will distract students rather than help them. Those concerns are understandable. The answer is not to force technology into every lesson, but to show teachers where it genuinely helps — and where it does not.
Content Matters More Than Hardware
A device without content is an empty box. For digital learning to work in Pakistan, the content needs to be in Urdu and regional languages as well as English, aligned with the national curriculum, and appropriate for the age and level of the student. It needs to work offline where internet is unreliable, and it needs to be accessible on low-cost devices.
There are promising efforts in this area, from government platforms to private EdTech startups, but the landscape is fragmented. A teacher looking for a good video on fractions, or a student looking for help with English grammar, may find plenty of material online, but not necessarily material that matches what they are supposed to learn in school. Quality control matters. So does curation — someone needs to sort the useful from the distracting.
The best digital content does not replace a teacher. It supports them. A short video can explain a difficult concept in a way that is hard to do on a blackboard. An interactive quiz can give a student immediate feedback. A digital library can give a child in a village access to books that their school library does not have. Those are real benefits, but they depend on the content being good, relevant and easy to find.
Connectivity and Power: The Basic Constraints
No discussion of the digital divide can ignore the basics: electricity and internet. Many schools in Pakistan still face power outages, and internet coverage, while improving, is uneven. In some areas, the signal is weak or expensive. In others, it is simply not there.
Solar power offers part of the answer for schools without reliable electricity, and it is already being used in some projects. Community internet, shared devices, and offline content that can be downloaded when connectivity is available are other practical solutions. These are not glamorous, but they are often more useful than a high-tech solution that assumes a stable connection that does not exist.
Cost is another constraint. Data is not free, and for a low-income family, the cost of a device and a data package can be a significant burden. Schools and governments need to think about affordability, not just availability. A programme that works for middle-class families in a city may not work for a farming family in a village.
What a Sensible Approach Looks Like
A sensible approach to digital learning in Pakistan would start with the classroom, not the device. It would ask: what do teachers need, what do students need, and what is the simplest technology that can help? Sometimes the answer is a tablet. Sometimes it is a television, a radio, or a printed workbook with a QR code. The technology should follow the need, not the other way round.
It would also invest in teachers as much as in hardware, in content as much as in connectivity, and in maintenance as much as in purchase. A computer lab that stops working after a year because no one can repair it is not a success. A programme that trains teachers once and then leaves them alone is not a success either.
Most importantly, it would measure success not by how many devices were distributed, but by whether children are learning more. That is a harder measure, but it is the only one that matters. A device count is easy to report. A learning outcome is harder to fudge.
Pakistan’s classrooms do not need to become high-tech showcases overnight. They need practical, affordable digital tools that help teachers teach and students learn, in the conditions that actually exist. That is a less exciting goal than a headline about thousands of tablets, but it is a more honest one. And in the long run, it is the one that will make a difference.


