The debate over creating new provinces in Pakistan took a sharp turn this month, and the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf now finds itself on both sides of it. Within the space of a few days, the party appeared to back a nationwide referendum on carving new provinces out of the existing four, and then its information secretary dismissed the whole proposal as absurd and futile. The whiplash captures something real about the issue: the idea of new provinces commands broad public sympathy, but the politics and the constitutional path to achieving it are far harder than a slogan suggests.
The proposal itself was first reported by The News on 8 November 2026. According to that report, the plan would redraw Pakistan from four provinces into twelve — Punjab divided into four, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa into three, Balochistan into three and Sindh into two — possibly after a nationwide referendum, with the change given effect through a 28th Constitutional Amendment. It is important to be clear about the status of that proposal: no draft has been published, no bill has been tabled in Parliament, and the National Assembly Speaker has said no draft has been received. The 28th Amendment, as a piece of legislation, does not yet exist. What exists is a proposal, discussed in the media and in political circles, and a set of public statements by ministers and party spokesmen that do not all point in the same direction.
How the referendum idea entered the debate
Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi floated the idea of a referendum on 12 November, and returned to it publicly on 21 November, saying that if the people say in a referendum that provinces should be formed, then “we should go ahead with it”. The appeal of a referendum is obvious. It allows a government to present a contentious constitutional change as the direct will of the people, and it sidesteps, at least in the short term, the parliamentary arithmetic that any amendment would require. It also frames the question in simple terms — do you want more provinces? — when the reality involves boundaries, capitals, resources, representation and the consent of the provinces being divided.
PTI’s chief whip, Amir Dogar, appeared to endorse that route. Speaking to reporters at Parliament House on Friday, he said a referendum was the most appropriate way to resolve the issue and that public opinion should determine it. He said the PTI would consult its core and political committees, and that Imran Khan’s decision would ultimately determine the party’s position. He also pointed to the party’s record, noting that Imran Khan had always favoured smaller administrative units and that the PTI’s 2018 election manifesto included the creation of a South Punjab province. On the face of it, that was a significant statement: the country’s largest opposition party, or at least its parliamentary leadership, was open to a referendum on new provinces.
Then the party pulled back
Within days, the position shifted. PTI Information Secretary Sheikh Waqas Akram called the proposal “absurd and futile”, a rejection that sits uneasily alongside Dogar’s remarks. The contradiction has not been fully explained, and it may reflect a genuine division inside the party, or a difference between the parliamentary party’s tactical instincts and the leadership’s strategic view, or simply the confusion that follows when a major constitutional proposal is floated without a draft, a timetable or a clear sponsor. Whatever the cause, the result is that PTI’s position on new provinces is now genuinely unclear — and that uncertainty matters, because no constitutional amendment can pass without broad political support.
The PPP, meanwhile, has taken a clearer line. Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari opposed a referendum on 17 November, arguing against putting the question to a popular vote. The PPP’s opposition is significant for two reasons. First, the party governs Sindh, one of the provinces that would be divided under the reported plan, and its resistance to splitting Sindh is long-standing. Second, the PPP’s support would be needed for any amendment to reach the two-thirds majorities required in Parliament. Its opposition, combined with PTI’s ambiguity, makes the parliamentary arithmetic for a 28th Amendment look difficult at best.
What the Constitution actually requires
Here the referendum idea runs into a hard constitutional fact. Article 239 of the Constitution requires a two-thirds majority in the assembly of any province whose boundaries would change, in addition to the parliamentary amendment process itself. A referendum result, however emphatic, cannot on its own create a province. The Constitution does not provide for a referendum to alter provincial boundaries, and no popular vote can substitute for the votes of the provincial assemblies concerned and the two-thirds majorities in the National Assembly and the Senate.
That matters because the provincial assemblies of Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan would each have to consent by a two-thirds majority to their own division. In practice, that means the governments and the dominant parties in each province would have to agree to surrender territory, resources and representation. It is one thing for voters in a national poll to say they favour more provinces in the abstract; it is another for a provincial assembly to vote to divide its own province. The history of this debate suggests that second step is where proposals stall.
A long history of unfinished proposals
The demand for new provinces is not new. The most concrete version of it has been the demand for a South Punjab province, which has been raised repeatedly over the past decade. Bills and resolutions on South Punjab have been introduced and discussed, but none has reached the statute book. The PTI’s 2018 manifesto included the creation of South Punjab province, and the party’s government took some administrative steps in that direction, but the constitutional change itself never happened. Other proposals — for a Hazara province, for the division of Sindh, for the splitting of Balochistan — have circulated for years without ever advancing to a vote.
The one major redrawing of the map in recent years points in the opposite direction. The 25th Amendment of 2018 merged the former Federally Administered Tribal Areas into Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, reducing the number of federally administered territories rather than increasing the number of provinces. That change was achieved through the constitutional process, with the required majorities and the consent of the assemblies concerned, and it shows both that the map can be changed and that doing so requires sustained political agreement rather than a single vote.
Why the idea keeps returning
Supporters of new provinces argue that Pakistan’s existing provinces are too large to govern effectively. Punjab, with a population larger than that of many countries, is the usual example. The argument is that smaller provinces would bring government closer to the people, improve service delivery, and give neglected regions — southern Punjab, Hazara, the Seraiki belt — a fairer share of resources and representation. There is public support for the idea. A Meridian National Barometer 2026 survey of 5,000 people reportedly found that 77 per cent supported the creation of more provinces, up from 54 per cent in 2022. That figure should be treated with the usual caution — surveys measure the mood of the moment, and support for an abstract idea does not always survive contact with the details of boundaries and resources — but it does suggest the demand is real and growing.
Critics raise different concerns. They argue that creating new provinces would multiply administrative costs, create new centres of patronage, and open up disputes over water, resources and representation that could take years to settle. They also note that the problems new provinces are supposed to solve — poor governance, weak service delivery, neglected regions — are not obviously problems of size. Smaller units can be just as badly governed as large ones, and the real constraint is often capacity and accountability rather than geography. There is also a political suspicion that the proposal is being raised now as a distraction, or as a bargaining chip in a wider negotiation over constitutional change, rather than as a serious legislative project.
Where the parties stand now
As of this week, the picture is this: the government, through the interior minister, has floated a referendum and said the people’s verdict should be followed. PTI has said two different things in the space of days — its chief whip open to a referendum, its information secretary calling the proposal absurd — and its final position awaits a decision by Imran Khan and the party’s committees. The PPP opposes a referendum. And the constitutional route, whatever the politics, runs through the provincial assemblies and two-thirds majorities in Parliament, not through a popular vote alone.
For the moment, then, the proposal for twelve provinces remains exactly that — a proposal, without a draft, without a bill, and without the political consensus it would need. It may yet become a serious legislative effort, or it may fade as quickly as it appeared. What is certain is that the debate will not be settled by a referendum, because a referendum cannot settle it. The hard work, if it is to happen at all, will be in the assemblies — and that is where the proposal’s supporters will have to win their argument. It is also worth remembering that constitutional change in Pakistan is rarely only about the text of an amendment; it is about the balance of power between the centre and the provinces, a balance that is also tested in quieter ways, such as the federal government’s 100-day development push for Azad Jammu and Kashmir, where the question is not how many provinces there are but how fairly the federation treats the territories it already has.
Source: Shafaqna Pakistan


